Uncertain Ground: Citizenship in an Age of Endless, Invisible War
Downloads:8625
Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
Create Date:2022-05-12 16:21:40
Update Date:2025-09-06
Status:finish
Author:Phil Klay
ISBN:0593299248
Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle
Reviews
Rachel,
Phil Klay's latest is a collection of nonfiction essays about war, citizenship and what it means to live in a country that's been continuously at war for two decades when most of the American public is oblivious to or indifferent about that fact。 This was a really insightful read, and if you're familiar with Klay's work from the short story collection Redeployment, you'll find the same thoughtfulness about the meaning of war and the obligation of civilians to consider the moral dimension of war Phil Klay's latest is a collection of nonfiction essays about war, citizenship and what it means to live in a country that's been continuously at war for two decades when most of the American public is oblivious to or indifferent about that fact。 This was a really insightful read, and if you're familiar with Klay's work from the short story collection Redeployment, you'll find the same thoughtfulness about the meaning of war and the obligation of civilians to consider the moral dimension of war familiar。 That said, the nature of an essay collection on one topic is that there's a fair bit of repetition between some of the essays, and I found myself getting a little tired of some of the threads that felt similar between pieces。 Klay's greatest strength is in pushing civilians to consider both what war is like and why we're able to distance ourselves from it, and I think this collection accomplishes that admirably。 。。。more
Kat,
What a powerful book。 Klay is an engaging, thoughtful, and skilled writer。 These essays touched my heart and expanded my thinking。 As someone who doesn't have any relatives or friends in the military, I appreciated his insights into what it has been like for the past decades。 Americans of all political persuasions would do well to read this collection。 Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the digital review copy。 What a powerful book。 Klay is an engaging, thoughtful, and skilled writer。 These essays touched my heart and expanded my thinking。 As someone who doesn't have any relatives or friends in the military, I appreciated his insights into what it has been like for the past decades。 Americans of all political persuasions would do well to read this collection。 Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the digital review copy。 。。。more
Jan,
US involvement in 21st century warfare is ignominious at best。 Written by a former (is there such a thing?) US Marine, this is a clear look at what we have done to a generation of soldiers who were sold a bill of goods by a succession of politicians。 It also quietly underscores how this country has betrayed another nation of people who looked to us for help and guidance in defeating their own enemies。 To read this series of essays is to feel a deep sadness for what the US has become and how its US involvement in 21st century warfare is ignominious at best。 Written by a former (is there such a thing?) US Marine, this is a clear look at what we have done to a generation of soldiers who were sold a bill of goods by a succession of politicians。 It also quietly underscores how this country has betrayed another nation of people who looked to us for help and guidance in defeating their own enemies。 To read this series of essays is to feel a deep sadness for what the US has become and how its young brave ones have been reduced to cannon fodder。 We owe the veterans more than the meagre honor they've been given。 This book needs to be read。I requested and received a free ebook copy from PENGUIN GROUP/The Penguin Press via NetGalley。 Thank you! 。。。more
Sarah,
Thank you to NetGalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review。This book is made up of a series of essays that the author wrote over the course of the Obama and Trump administrations。 He has ambitious goals in his writing as he grapples with figuring out how we got involved in a war that just kept going; what war meant to him personally; what war says about Americans; how the war(s) have distorted our politics and culture; how politics have shifted to shield war from our view; ho Thank you to NetGalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review。This book is made up of a series of essays that the author wrote over the course of the Obama and Trump administrations。 He has ambitious goals in his writing as he grapples with figuring out how we got involved in a war that just kept going; what war meant to him personally; what war says about Americans; how the war(s) have distorted our politics and culture; how politics have shifted to shield war from our view; how war relates to questions of faith; how we respond to collective and individual trauma and how to reckon with guilt and atonement。 Klay touches on each of these aspects throughout his essays and he shares plenty of stories regarding the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan。 His writing is clear and heartfelt as he talks about his views/feelings about the wars。Unfortunately, I couldn't give this book more than 3/5 stars。 I didn't really learn anything new or gain a better insight into the conflicts and people involved。 I'm a bit of a news junkie so I was already aware of many of the issues discussed in his essays。 Also, I would have appreciated some links/advice to veterans looking for help rather than primarily focusing on the hopelessness and disappointment of postwar America。 。。。more